Legislation Details

File #: 1641    Version: 1 Name:
Type: Consent Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/18/2026 In control: Governing Board
On agenda: 11/5/2026 Final action:
Title: Presentation, discussion, and possible action on recommendation to adopt an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty relating to Mission Trails At Camino Real (HTC 19408 / CMTS 5468)
Sponsors: Sascha Stremler
Attachments: 1. Agreed Final Order - Mission Trails_UploadToLegistar
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

title

Presentation, discussion, and possible action on recommendation to adopt an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty relating to Mission Trails At Camino Real (HTC 19408 / CMTS 5468)

end

 

RECOMMENDED ACTION

 

recommendation

WHEREAS, Mission Trails at Camino Real (HTC 19408 / CMTS # 5468), owned by El Camino Real Associates, LLC, has uncorrected compliance findings relating to the applicable land use restriction agreement and the associated statutory and rule requirements;

 

WHEREAS, TDHCA identified findings of noncompliance during its regularly scheduled 2025 file monitoring review at Mission Trails at Camino Real, and referred that noncompliance for an administrative penalty when it was not fully and timely corrected;

 

WHEREAS, unresolved compliance findings include two annual data collection violations, one lease violation, and seven household income violations;

 

WHEREAS, an Enforcement Committee informal conference was held on September 10, 2026, and Owner agreed, subject to Board approval, to enter into an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty of $5,000.00, with $1,000.00 due upon signature and the remainder subject to subject to probation and forgiveness if Owner submits full corrections as required by the Order; and

 

WHEREAS, staff has based its recommendations for an Agreed Final Order on the Department’s rules for administrative penalties and an assessment of each and all of the statutory factors to be considered in assessing such penalties, applied specifically to the facts and circumstances present in this case.

 

NOW, therefore, it is hereby

 

RESOLVED, that an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty of $5,000.00, subject to partial forgiveness as outlined above, substantially in the form presented at this meeting, and authorizing any non-substantive technical corrections, is hereby adopted as the order of this Board.

end

 

BACKGROUND

PROPERTY INFORMATION: Mission Trails at Camino Real (Mission Trails) received a housing tax credit allocation during 2019, to build and operate 352 units in San Marcos, Hays County, with 282 units restricted at 60% AMI, and the remainder at market rate. There are 15 buildings.

The federal compliance period will end on December 31, 2035, and the extended use period will expire on December 31, 2050.

 

OWNERSHIP AND PROPERTY MANAGEMENT: Mission Trails is owned by El Camino Real Associates, LLC. Its managing member is an affiliate of The Michaels Organization (TMO), and is controlled by its sole trustee, Paul Chan, and officers, Mark Morgan, Genevieve Bauer, Cheree Lujan, Joseph F. Purcell, and Catherine A. Freas. The property is self-managed by Michaels Management-Affordable.

 

REFERRED VIOLATIONS SUBJECT TO ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES: TDHCA conducted a file monitoring review on June 25, 2025, and the Compliance Division set a corrective action deadline of November 9, 2025. The property submitted a timely response, but failed to respond to a 10-day corrective action notice with a deadline of March 13, 2026. The Compliance Division referred the following findings to the Enforcement Committee for an administrative penalty on June 23, 2026. Further corrective documentation was then submitted between July 22, 2026, and September 11, 2026, after intervention by the Committee. An informal conference was held on September 10, 2026.

 

1.                     Findings that were resolved after referral:

a.                     Failure to implement annual utility allowance updates.

b.                     Failure to perform Annual Data Collection for unit 4104.

c.                     Lease noncompliance for failure to sign Tenant Rights and Resources Guide Acknowledgment form for units 2307 and 4101.

d.                     Lease noncompliance for units 4104 and 5107, with leases that did not include prohibition of evictions or terminations of tenancy for other than good cause, or prohibition on lock-outs.

e.                     Household income and/or eligibility noncompliance for unit 13301.

 

2.                     Findings that remain unresolved:

a.                     Failure to perform Annual Data Collection for units 2307, 10106.

b.                     Household income and/or eligibility noncompliance for units 3202, 3308, 4301, 7106, 12302, 15107, and 15301.

c.                     Lease noncompliance for unit 11106, with a lease that did not include prohibition of evictions or terminations of tenancy for other than good cause, or prohibition on lock-outs.

 

FACTORS CONSIDERED TO DETERMINE ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTY: The Committee analyzed the required statutory factors for determining an appropriate administrative penalty as follows:

 

1.                     The seriousness, extent, and gravity of the violations, and whether a hazard is posed to the health, safety, or economic welfare of the public:

 

There is no uncorrected physical noncompliance, and the property scored 90 out of 100 during its 2025 National Standards for the Physical Inspection of Real Estate (NSPIRE) inspection. At the time of referral, all of the uncorrected unit noncompliance noted above remained uncorrected because the affected units were vacant. Some of the monitoring issues were significant, like failure to include income certifications in the files, which is core to the program. However, the economic hazard for the public is limited because of the property’s high vacancy rate; there still were plenty of units available to the public despite the noncompliance. Additionally, the Committee was uncertain whether the affected households were truly ineligible, noting that although compiling proper documentation is important, failure to properly document income eligibility is less serious than a household that is truly above the income limit.

 

2.                     History of previous violations: The Michaels Organization controls 57 actively monitored TDHCA developments. There are no prior orders for this ownership group. Prior administrative penalty referrals during the past three years were minor, and were resolved quickly without penalty assessment, including a Uniform Physical Condition Standards (UPCS) referral with two referred deficiencies, a UPCS referral with incomplete work orders requiring clarification regarding previously completed repairs, and a file monitoring referral for incomplete documentation to confirm a rent refund for one unit. The referral for Mission Trails is the owner’s only referral since May 2024, but the Committee’s informal conference for Mission Trails was mandatory due to a pattern of repeated referrals during the past three years, and there were concerns about the property’s high vacancy rate.

 

3.                     Efforts made to correct the violations: Property did submit timely corrections in response to the initial corrective action deadline, but failed to respond to the 10-day cure notice. It was not possible to correct all of the noncompliance due to a vacancy issue, but the property should have responded with a corrective plan for the vacant units. Further corrections were submitted after the informal conference and are incorporated into this board item, but were not considered by the Committee due to timing.

 

4.                     Any other matters that justice may require: The Michaels Organization has a large ownership portfolio with 57 actively monitored developments. As noted above, this property is the organization’s only penalty referral since 2024.

 

All of the referred unit problems relate to units that were vacant at the time of referral, and the unit status report shows a significant vacancy problem. As of the informal conference date on September 10, 2026, there were 181 occupied units and 171 vacant units, causing negative net cash flow for the development. This level of instability and negative net cash flow is highly unusual for a property of this age without a contributing casualty loss event or other type of problem taking units offline. The vacancy rate seen here is partly due to an oversaturated rental market in San Marcos; however, it is also clear that there was poor onsite management, with little owner oversight. Ultimately, the property failed to adjust rents to meet market reality. Tenants started moving out and were not replaced because rents were too high, and the problem soon started to impact cash flow and the property’s ability to do maintenance turn-overs. The owner states that there were leadership problems.

 

Ownership has implemented a lot of changes to prevent recurrence, including leadership changes, replacing onsite management, a new electronic file system, investing in training, and implementing new systems for ensuring compliance, including monthly audits and regular meetings between compliance management and onsite staff.

 

TMO has deployed its operational lease-up team in order to address the high vacancy rate, treating the property as a new lease-up. To address market conditions that prior onsite management had seemingly ignored, the lease-up team reduced rents, added move-in specials, and water and trash are now included in the rent. Ownership has also focused on maintenance turn-overs. Occupancy is improving as a result of these efforts, and is currently at 76.7% as of October 20, 2026, with an additional 15 new move-ins scheduled within the next 30 days, and projections to reach 86% by the end of Q4.                     

 

5.                     Amount necessary to deter future violations: The Committee remains concerned about financial instability, but the changes noted above appear to be working toward stabilization, and it is important to keep that trend moving in the right direction. The Committee determined that a penalty is appropriate despite the instability, but recommended a significant forgivable portion as an incentive to comply. In light of the above factors, the Committee recommends an Agreed Final Order assessing administrative penalties of $5,000.00, with $1,000.00 to be paid at signing, and the remainder to be deferred and forgiven if the owner complies with the Order.

 

RECOMMENDATION: Accordingly, after consideration of all appropriate factors, the Enforcement Committee and Executive Director recommend an Agreed Final Order for an administrative penalty in the amount of $5,000.00 against El Camino Real Associates, LLC, with $1,000.00 to be paid at signing, and the remainder to be deferred and forgiven if the Order’s terms are met.