Legislation Details

File #: 1640    Version: 1 Name:
Type: Consent Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/18/2026 In control: Governing Board
On agenda: 11/5/2026 Final action:
Title: Presentation, discussion, and possible action on recommendations to debar The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Family Irrevocable Trust, Peter Huu Le, and Diana Thi Nguyen, and to adopt an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty, both relating to Dale Meadows f/k/a St. John Colony (HOME 530200 / CMTS 4001)
Sponsors: Sascha Stremler
Attachments: 1. Debarment Order - Dale Meadows, 2. Agreed Final Order - Dale Meadows, 3. Attachment 1. Follow-up Inspection Report from 5/20/2026 and 9/4/2026, 4. Attachment 2. 2024 NSPIRE Report, 5. Attachment 3. 2025 NSPIRE Report, 6. Attachment 4. Selection of photographs from the 9/4/2026 and 5/20/2026 Reinspections
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

title

Presentation, discussion, and possible action on recommendations to debar The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Family Irrevocable Trust, Peter Huu Le, and Diana Thi Nguyen, and to adopt an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty, both relating to Dale Meadows f/k/a St. John Colony (HOME 530200 / CMTS 4001)

end

RECOMMENDED ACTION

 

recommendation

WHEREAS, Dale Meadows f/k/a St. John Colony (HOME 530200 / CMTS 4001), owned by The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Family Irrevocable Trust, Peter Huu Le, and Diana Thi Nguyen (collectively, the Responsible Parties), has uncorrected compliance findings relating to the applicable land use restriction agreement and the associated statutory and rule requirements;

 

WHEREAS, the Responsible Parties have a history of violations, and previously signed Agreed Final Orders from 2015 and 2022, agreeing to pay partially probated and deferred administrative penalties as an incentive to comply, and requiring corrections of noncompliance;

 

WHEREAS, Dale Meadows is on an annual inspection schedule, and scored below 50 out of 100 on its 2024 and 2025 National Standards for the Physical Inspection of Real Estate (NSPIRE) inspections;

 

WHEREAS, the Responsible Parties submitted corrective documentation representing full completion of all noncompliance, but subsequent TDHCA reinspections on May 20, 2026 and September 4, 2026, to confirm resolution showed misrepresentations, with multiple issues of noncompliance not corrected as represented;

 

WHEREAS, the Responsible Parties were referred for debarment for submitting misrepresentations to the Department, and for scoring below 50 on two NSPIRE inspections;

WHEREAS, the Responsible Parties were also referred for an administrative penalty for the noncompliance that was confirmed to be unresolved;

 

WHEREAS, Peter Huu Le attended an informal conference with the Enforcement Committee (Committee) on September 10, 2026;

 

WHEREAS, the Committee recommended a 10-year debarment and an administrative penalty of $7,875.00, with a $4,000.00 portion of the penalty due in two payments, and the remainder to be deferred and forgiven if the next NSPIRE inspection to be conducted on or after March 15, 2027 confirms full resolution of the remaining noncompliance and the inspection score is at least 70 out of 100;

 

WHEREAS, on October 7, 2026, the TDHCA Executive Director issued a debarment determination notice recommending a 10-year debarment term for all of the Responsible Parties, and notifying the Responsible Parties that the Department also intended to seek administrative penalties;

 

WHEREAS, the Responsible Parties did not appeal the debarment and have agreed to sign an Agreed Final Order for the administrative penalty assessment;

 

WHEREAS, staff has based its debarment recommendation on the Department’s rules for debarment and an assessment of each and all of the material factors that are to be considered in determining a recommended period of debarment, applied specifically to the facts and circumstances present in this case; and

 

WHEREAS, staff has based its administrative penalty recommendation on the Department’s rules for administrative penalties and an assessment of each and all of the statutory factors identified to be considered in assessing such penalties, applied specifically to the facts and circumstances present in this case.

 

NOW, therefore, it is hereby

 

RESOLVED, that a Final Order of Debarment for a 10-year term for The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Family Irrevocable Trust, Peter Huu Le, and Diana Thi Nguyen, substantially in the form presented at this meeting, and authorizing any non-substantive technical corrections, is hereby adopted as the order of this Board; and

 

RESOLVED, that an Agreed Final Order assessing an administrative penalty of $7,875.00, subject to partial deferral and forgiveness as outlined above, substantially in the form presented at this meeting, and authorizing any non-substantive technical corrections, is hereby adopted as the order of this Board.

end

 

BACKGROUND

PROPERTY INFORMATION: Dale Meadows (HOME 530200 / CMTS 4001) (the Property) received a HOME loan in 2002 to install new manufactured housing units in Dale, Caldwell County, Texas. There are currently four scattered-site units restricted at 80% AMI, of which units 108 and 200 are vacant, and units 201 and 307 are occupied. Additional manufactured houses at the site are also owned by the Responsible Parties, but are not restricted by TDHCA. The HOME loan was extinguished when the county foreclosed due to unpaid property taxes in 2010, but the HOME LURA remained in place. The HOME LURA was then extended to ensure a minimum 20-year affordability period, and will expire September 26, 2031.

RESPONSIBLE PARTIES IN CONTROL: Peter Huu Le and Diana Nguyen, husband and wife, purchased the property personally in 2013, after the foreclosure sale, and transferred ownership to The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Irreocable Trust in 2023. They did not engage in the required TDHCA ownership transfer process in accordance with 10 TAC §10.406. Therefore, for enforcement purposes, TDHCA will consider all three parties to have ownership and control authority.

 

PROPERTY MANAGEMENT: The Property is self-managed by Peter Huu Le.

VIOLATIONS SUBJECT TO DISCRETIONARY DEBARMENT:

1.                     Tex. Gov’t. Code 2306.0504(b) states, “(b) The department may debar a person from participation in a department program on the basis of the person's past failure to comply with any condition imposed by the department in the administration of its programs.”

 

2.                     10 TAC §2.401(a)(5) states: “(a) The Department may debar a Responsible Party, a Consultant and/or a Vendor who has exhibited past failure to comply with any condition imposed by the Department in the administration of its programs. A Responsible Party, Consultant or Vendor may be referred to the Committee for Debarment for any of the following: […] (5) Providing fraudulent information, knowingly falsified documentation, or other intentional or negligent material misrepresentation or omission with regard to any documentation, certification or other representation made to the Department.”

 

3.                     The Responsible Parties were referred for debarment under 10 TAC §2.401(a)(5) for submitting misrepresentations to the Department. On April 17, 2026, Peter Huu Le uploaded written documentation via the Compliance Monitoring and Tracking System (“CMTS”) representing the full correction of all deficiencies identified by the Department during the NSPIRE inspection conducted at the Property on November 13, 2025. On May 5, 2026, the Department notified Respondent that the Property would be reinspected on May 20, 2026, to verify corrections, and to ensure that the condition of the property was in better repair. During that reinspection, the Department found that several deficiencies were not repaired as represented by Mr. Le in the corrective documentation, violating 10 TAC §2.401(a)(5). After referral for debarment, Mr. Le uploaded further corrective documentation on August 15, 2026, and the Department issued a notice on August 29, 2026, indicating that the property would be reinspected on September 4, 2026, to verify corrections, and to ensure that the property was in better repair. Both follow-up inspections showed uncorrected noncompliance despite Mr. Le’s representations. See inspection report at Attachment 1.

VIOLATIONS SUBJECT TO MANDATORY DEBARMENT:

1.                     Tex. Gov’t. Code 2306.0504(c) states, “(c) The department shall debar a person from participation in a department program if the person: (1) materially or repeatedly violates any condition imposed by the department in connection with the administration of a department program […].”

 

2.                     10 TAC §2.401(c) states, “(c) Debarment for violations of the Department's Multifamily Programs. The Department shall debar any Responsible Party, Consultant, and/or Vendor who has materially or repeatedly violated any condition imposed by the Department in connection with the administration of a Department program, including but not limited to a material or repeated violation of a land use restriction agreement (LURA) or Contract. Subsection (d) of this section provides the criteria the Department will use to determine if there has been a material violation of a LURA […].”

 

3.                     10 TAC §2.401(d) states, “(d) Material violations of a LURA. A Responsible Party, Consultant, and/or Vendor will be considered to have materially violated a LURA, Program Agreement, or condition imposed by the Department and shall be referred to the committee for mandatory Debarment if they: […] (1) Control a Development that has, on more than one occasion scored 50 or less on a UPCS inspection or has, on more than one occasion scored 50 or less on a NSPIRE inspection, or any combination thereof. The Compliance Division or Enforcement Committee may temporarily decrease this NSPIRE score referral threshold for a Development, with approval by the Executive Director, for a period of time not longer than one year, so long as the referral score threshold is applied evenly to all Developments with similar types of violations;”

 

4.                     The Responsible Parties were referred for debarment under 10 TAC §2.401(d)(1) for scoring below 50 on an NSPIRE inspection on more than one occasion. The Property scored 19 out of 100 on the NSPIRE inspection conducted on November 6, 2024, and then scored 32 out of 100 on the NSPIRE Inspection conducted on November 13, 2025, violating the low score threshold at 10 TAC §2.401(d)(1). Copies of the NSPIRE reports are at Attachments 2 and 3.

 

5.                     Debarment is mandatory for a violation of 10 TAC §2.401(d), and the Responsible Parties are not eligible for a Voluntary Non-Participation Agreement.

 

VIOLATIONS SUBJECT TO ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES: In addition to the debarment referrals, the Property was also referred for administrative penalties for:

1.                     2025 NSPIRE noncompliance that was confirmed to be unresolved during the reinspection on May 20, 2026. A copy of the reinspection report is at Attachment 1. Only the uncorrected noncompliance was referred, and the maximum potential administrative penalty is $7,375.00.

 

2.                     Failure to timely submit the 2025 Annual Owner’s Compliance Report that was due on April 30, 2026, reporting data as of December 31, 2025. The report was submitted on September 11, 2026, after the informal conference was held. The maximum potential administrative penalty is $500.00.

RESPONSES BY RESPONSIBLE PARTIES: Mr. Le claims that he did repair all of the NSPIRE findings that are subject to the misrepresentation allegations, and that the TDHCA inspector was mistaken when she found multiple items to be unrepaired. He also claims that any poor unit conditions are caused by tenants. He states that he has now fully remodeled units 108, 200 and 201, and that unit 307 is pending a full remodel, writing on August 15, 2026, “As the owner of Dale Village, I apologize for the inconvenience. The mobile home park of Dale Village is way out of the county, making it tough for potential tenants to find decent jobs around. It can even take a year to find potential tenants even if I lower rent prices below market price. The past few times that we have found a tenant for these properties, we try to help orient them to living in the properties and to take care of them. Unfortunately, despite our best efforts, we cannot control their actions. Whenever a tenant moves out of our property, it costs thousands of dollars and hundreds of work hours to make them livable again. I once again, apologize for the inconvenience. I have sent pictures of 3 houses with as many as the uncorrected fixes that was noted that we were able to get to. Specifically Units 108, 200, 201. We have not gotten to 307 yet, I will remodel & repair all issues with the house within the next few weeks.”

FACTORS CONSIDERED TO DETERMINE RECOMMENDED DEBARMENT TERM: The Committee considered the following factors, pursuant to 10 TAC §2.401(j):

1.                     Repeated enforcement occurrences and history of previous violations:

 

a.                     Debarment: There are no prior debarment referrals.

 

b.                     Administrative Penalty: There is an extensive administrative penalty referral history for the Responsible Parties. Mr. Le is generally responsive and usually submits corrections when requested, but he has difficulty with basic compliance requirements, and his submissions are repeatedly incomplete. He requested technical support and TDHCA assistance between 2013 and 2016, and then attended training in 2016. Referral history includes:

 

i.                     2016 Agreed Final Order. $1,000.00 administrative penalty paid for file monitoring noncompliance. All findings were ultimately corrected, but were submitted a month after the Order deadline. Findings included: household income for two units that were not screened, annual self-certifications that were not collected for two units; incomplete written policies and procedures; leases that did not contain required language; and missing lease disclosures for three units.

 

ii.                     2021 Uniform Physical Condition Standards (UPCS). Score of 84 out of 100. Mr. Le submitted corrections for exigent health and safety findings prior to inspection report issuance, but did not respond to the rest of the findings on the inspection report. Noncompliance was resolved informally prior to setting an informal conference, the score was good, and it had been years since the last referral, so the matter was closed informally.

 

iii.                     2022 Agreed Final Order. $2,250.00 administrative penalty paid for file monitoring noncompliance. All findings were corrected per the Order. Findings included: household income for two units that were not screened, and a self-certification that was not collected for one unit.

 

iv.                     2024 File Monitoring: Property was referred for file monitoring noncompliance, however, it was referred early in the monitoring process, before any files were actually reviewed. The owner had misunderstood and thought the onsite file monitoring review was a physical inspection, so he did not have any files present at the site. The Compliance Division agreed to close this referral informally if the owner complied with the monitoring review and corrected any identified noncompliance. The review was ultimately closed out during January 2025 without a further referral.

 

2.                     Seriousness of underlying issues: The misrepresentations submitted to TDHCA are very serious, as are the multiple inspection scores below 50. Misrepresentations included serious health and safety concerns like non-functional GFCI’s within six feet of a water source, exposed electrical conductors, a damaged entry door lock for an occupied unit, failure to install smoke detectors, damaged entry stairs, an extensive insect infestation in one unit, and extreme amounts of litter and debris throughout the site.

 

3.                     Presence or absence of corrective action, including corrective action to install new responsible persons and ensure they are qualified and properly trained: Mr. Le indicates that he cannot afford to hire outside management, and that he performs all repairs himself. He claims that he repaired everything as represented to the Department on April 17, 2026 and August 15, 2026, and that TDHCA staff was mistaken during its re-inspections performed on May 20, 2026 and September 4, 2026.

 

The Committee considered his claim, and noted that there were a number of half-truths in the corrective action. For example, Mr. Le replaced outlets, however, the outlets failed the Department’s GFCI testing due to improper installation. Similarly, Mr. Le installed some screws in an entry door to address noncompliance relating to a door lock, but the lock still did not properly engage. The Committee observed that Mr. Le was doing the least possible action toward repairs, mistaking activity for achievement. For example, Mr. Le had purchased smoke detectors, but admitted that he did not actually install or test them, leaving installation to tenants, or putting them aside to install after he completed all work in the unit. In all three examples, Mr. Le did do something, but his “repair” did not actually fix the deficiencies, and the effect is the same as if he had ignored the deficiencies entirely. Furthermore, replacing the outlets himself arguably created an even worse health and safety hazard due to improper installation.

 

4.                     Other material factors: This property was originally known as St. John’s Colony. The original owner had legal orders preventing him from accessing the site, contributing to extensive file and physical noncompliance. The property was ultimately foreclosed by the county in 2010, due to delinquent property taxes. The TDHCA HOME LURA remained in place, and was extended to ensure a minimum compliant 20-year affordability period. Although the property had a difficult start, the current Responsible Parties have owned it since 2013, and are responsible for ensuring that it is maintained in decent, safe, and habitable condition. The property scored 84 out of 100 during its 2021 UPCS inspection, but subsequently declined to a score of 19 out of 100 in 2024, and a score of 32 out of 100 during 2025. Furthermore, despite this pending enforcement action, the TDHCA inspector who performed the follow-up inspections to confirm corrections on May 20, 2026, and September 4, 2026, observed conditions continuing to decline at each successive inspection, with extreme amounts of trash and debris scattered throughout the site, deteriorating and unsafe front porches and entry stairs, and new severe water damage caused by a plumbing leak behind the sink in Bathroom 2 of occupied unit 307. While some categories of noncompliance observed during the referred NSPIRE inspections are due to the transition from the UPCS protocol to the NSPIRE protocol and contributed toward a low score, the Committee voted not to consider adjusting the score threshold as permitted under 10 TAC §2.401(d)(1) because the inspection photographs show poor conditions supporting a low score below 50.

 

During the informal conference, Mr. Le was more concerned about making vacant units 108 and 200 ready for occupancy than he was about repairing occupied unit 307. He did not appear to be concerned about the deficiencies identified by TDHCA, deflecting responsibility to the tenants, arguing that the units are in good condition at move-in, and that tenants cause all of the deficiencies. The general poor conditions observed do not support that conclusion, although there are some exceptions. For example, the cockroach infestation at unit 307 is likely due to housekeeping problems. However, it is still the owner’s responsibility to ensure that the deficiency is adequately addressed. A regular treatment program is needed due to the extensive infestation. Mr. Le indicated that an exterminator treated the unit twice, but admitted that there is no ongoing treatment program. He has also performed his own insect treatment, which is not permitted for rental properties in Texas since he is not a licensed exterminator. Additionally, the entire site is covered in litter, debris, broken appliances, and sharp objects, and the grass is regularly overgrown. Mr. Le states that tenants are responsible for mowing the lawn and keeping yards clear of debris. When pressed on the matter, he indicated that he will clean up the debris when he finishes his remodeling work. See sample photographs at Attachment 4. 

 

Annual Reports show positive net cash flow, and it is clear that the owner is trying to invest the least amount of money possible in order to maximize cash flow, performing repairs himself even when he is not qualified to do so. The Committee also questioned accuracy of the financials submitted to the Department. For example, the 2025 Annual Owner’s Compliance Report (“AOCR”) had not yet been submitted at the time of the conference, but the 2024 financial report showed $28,000.00 for repairs. The 2025 AOCR submitted after the informal conference showed $22,000.00 for repairs. The Committee questioned accuracy since minimal repairs were observed at the four restricted units.

 

Mr. Le does not participate in any other TDHCA programs, and controls no other TDHCA properties. He indicates he has no intention to participate in the future. Continued future noncompliance and penalty referrals are likely unless Mr. Le hires an outside management company or compliance consultant to assist with tenant files, and contractors to repair NSPIRE noncompliance that are outside of his expertise and licenses. Outside hiring is unlikely due to the property size and remote location.

RECOMMENDATION: After consideration of all appropriate factors, the Enforcement Committee and Executive Director recommend the issuance by the Board of the following orders:

1.                     A Final Order of Debarment for a 10-year term for The Peter Le & Diana Nguyen Family Irrevocable Trust, Peter Huu Le, and Diana Thi Nguyen; and

 

2.                     An Agreed Final Order for an administrative penalty of $7,875.00, with a $4,000.00 portion of the penalty due in two payments, and the remainder to be deferred and forgiven if the next NSPIRE inspection to be conducted on or after March 15, 2027 confirms full resolution of the remaining noncompliance and the inspection score is at least 70 out of 100.

Attachments:

1.                     Follow-up Inspection Report from 5/20/2026 and 9/4/2026

2.                     2024 NSPIRE Report

3.                     2025 NSPIRE Report

4.                     Selection of photographs from the 9/4/2026 and 5/20/2026 Reinspections