Legislation Details

File #: 1653    Version: 1 Name:
Type: Action Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/27/2026 In control: Governing Board
On agenda: 11/5/2026 Final action:
Title: Presentation, discussion, and possible action on the adoption of the repeal of 10 TAC Chapter 11 concerning the Housing Tax Credit Program Qualified Allocation Plan, adoption of new 10 TAC Chapter 11 concerning the Housing Tax Credit Program Qualified Allocation Plan, and directing their publication for adoption in the Texas Register following the statutory opportunity for gubernatorial acceptance, revision, or rejection
Sponsors: Cody Campbell
Attachments: 1. 2027 QAP November - Blackline from Sept Reg Version (Flattened), 2. 2027 QAP Public Comments Combined (Flattened)
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

title

Presentation, discussion, and possible action on the adoption of the repeal of 10 TAC Chapter 11 concerning the Housing Tax Credit Program Qualified Allocation Plan, adoption of new 10 TAC Chapter 11 concerning the Housing Tax Credit Program Qualified Allocation Plan, and directing their publication for adoption in the Texas Register following the statutory opportunity for gubernatorial acceptance, revision, or rejection

 

end

RECOMMENDED ACTION

 

recommendation

WHEREAS, the Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs (the Department) is authorized by Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.053, Subchapter DD, to make Housing Tax Credit allocations for the State of Texas;

 

WHEREAS, pursuant to Tex Gov’t Code §2306.053, the Department is authorized to adopt rules governing the administration of the Department and its programs;

                     

WHEREAS, after approval with modifications by the Department’s Board on September 3, 2026, the rule was made available for public comment in Texas Register and on the Department’s website through October 9, 2026;

 

WHEREAS, public comment was received by 41 commenters, staff has prepared a reasoned response to those comments summarized in the preambles attached, and where applicable, has proposed responsive revisions for adoption;

 

WHEREAS, pursuant to Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.6724, the Board shall adopt the Qualified Allocation Plan (QAP) and, on or before November 15, submit it to the Governor to approve, reject, or modify and approve not later than December 1; and

 

WHEREAS, upon action by the Governor, the Department will submit the QAP for its publication in the Texas Register;

 

NOW, therefore, it is hereby

 

RESOLVED, that the adoption of the repeal of 10 TAC Chapter 11, and adoption of new 10 TAC Chapter 11 concerning the Housing Tax Credit Qualified Allocation Plan together with the preambles presented to this meeting, are hereby approved and recommended to the Governor; and

 

FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Executive Director and his designees be and each of them are hereby authorized, empowered, and directed, for and on behalf of the Department, to cause the Qualified Allocation Plan, together with the changes, if any, made at this meeting and the preambles, in the form presented to this meeting, to be delivered to the Governor, not later than November 15, 2026, for his review and approval, and to cause the Qualified Allocation Plan, as approved, approved with changes, or rejected by the Governor, to thereafter be published in the Texas Register for adoption and in connection therewith, make such non-substantive technical corrections as they may deem necessary to effectuate the foregoing.

 

end

BACKGROUND

 

Comment Period: The Board approved the proposed 10 TAC Chapter 11, the QAP, on September 18, 2026. The draft of the QAP was made available on the Department’s website and was published in the Texas Register edition dated September 19, 2026. Staff hosted an in-person roundtable discussion on May 20, 2026, in Austin and a virtual roundtable discussion on June 25, 2026, to discuss a variety of QAP topics. The roundtables were not considered hearings for accepting comment but rather served as a forum at which staff could engage with potential commenters, and stakeholders to answer questions and brainstorm ideas, with the intent that each attendee could then make informed comment prior to the comment deadline.

 

Staff received written comments from 41 commenters by the deadline. Staff has reviewed all comments and provided a reasoned response to these comments in the following preamble.

 

Rule-Making Timeline: Upon Board approval, the proposed 2027 QAP was posted to the Department’s website and published in the Texas Register. Public comment was accepted from September 18, 2026, and October 9, 2026. Staff then considered and prepared reasoned responses to public comments as part of the final action of the QAP that is brought before the Board on November 5, 2026, for approval. Subsequently, the QAP will be submitted to the Office of the Governor not later than November 15, 2026, for him to approve, approve with changes, or reject. Upon the Governor’s approval, approval with modifications, or rejection, which must occur no later than December 1, 2026, the adopted 2027 QAP will be published in the Texas Register and posted to the Department’s website.

 

Summary of Proposed Changes: While not inclusive of all changes proposed, a description of the more significant recommendations that are considered changes of policy are described below. The vast majority of changes to the 2027 QAP Draft are copy-edits for clarity and readability. As such, they will not be included in the summary below. Should any conflict exist between this summary and the proposed text of the rule, the rule itself will be controlling.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter A

§11.6(d)(1) Definitions: Achievable Affordable Rent- Added a new definition.

 

§11.6(d)(102) Definitions: Pro Forma Rent- Added Achievable Affordable Rent to the definition.

 

§11.6(d)(114) Definitions: Site Demographics Characteristics Report- Added a new definition.

 

§11.2(a) Program Calendar for Housing Tax Credits- This section has been modified to reflect dates for the 2027 Application round.

 

§11.5(3)(F) At-Risk Set-Aside- Condensed language to simply reference Code §42.

 

§11.6(3) Award Recommendation Methodology- Added clarifying language regarding Staff Application review process.

 

§11.6(3)(C)(iv) Initial Application Selection in Each Subregion (Step 3)- Added language for requiring Application to include a written agreement between Applicant and Education Provider.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(i) Tie Breaker Factors: Parks- Added language to disqualify park if facilities are located on a school campus.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(i) Tie Breaker Factors: Parks- Added language to allow unimproved land that is considered a wilderness area with recreation use that includes signage and established hiking/walking trails.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(iii) Tie Breaker Factors: Full-Service Grocery Store- Removed language for grocery stores to require selling seafood to be considered eligible as a tiebreaker option.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(iii) Tie Breaker Factors: Full-Service Grocery Store- Added language to allow grocery stores with paid memberships to qualify as a tie breaker.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(v) Tie Breaker Factors: Pharmacy- Added a new tie breaker. Added language listing requirements for a pharmacy to be considered eligible as a tie breaker option.

 

§11.7(2)(A)(vi) Tie Breaker Factors: Urgent Care- Added a new tie breaker. Added language listing requirements for urgent cares to be considered eligible as a tie breaker option.

 

§11.7(2)(B) Tie Breaker Factors Linear Measurements- Added clarifying language regarding the parcel boundaries being established by the central appraisal district.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter B

§11.101(a)(2)(E) HUD Mitigation- Added language stating the Department will accept mitigation efforts directly from HUD based sources.

 

§11.101(a)(3)(C) Crime- Added language for Reconstruction Applications to be excluded from being exempt for triggering a Crime NRF.

 

§11.101(b)(1)(A)(xi) Ineligible Developments- Added language that a Site located in a census tract with a poverty rate above 40% (or 55% in regions 11 and 13) will be considered ineligible unless a resolution from the Governing Body is provided.

 

§11.101(b)(4)(K) Mandatory Development Amenities- Replaced language to lighting for this amenity. 

 

§11.101(b)(4)(L) Mandatory Development Amenities- Added language to require all heating and air-conditioning to be provided by an electric heat pump system or natural gas. Added language to give exemptions for Rehabilitation Developments, but excluding Reconstruction Developments from the exemption.

 

§11.101(b)(5)(C)(iv)(VIII) Community Space for Resident Supportive Services: Design/Landscaping amenities- Added a new 1-point scoring item for including at least two elevators for Sites that have each unit above the first floor.

 

§11.101(b)(7) Resident Supportive Services- Added language to require a 45-day notice be issued to tenants on any supportive service changes.

 

§11.101(b)(7)(B)(iii) Children Supportive Services- Added 3-point scoring option for services intended to track and address school truancy.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter C

§11.202(1)(P) Ineligible Applicants- Added language stating an Applicant would be ineligible if Applicant violates Tex Prop. Code §5.253.

 

§11.204(6)(B) Gap Financing- Added language requiring all soft or below market rate financing to be committed by a 10% test for Competitive Applications.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter D

§11.302(d)(1) Operating Feasibility: Income- Added Achievable Affordable Rent to the section.

 

§11.302(d)(1)(iii) Operating Feasibility: Achievable Affordable Rents- Added Achievable Affordable Rent for Underwriter tests on a Development’s operating feasibility.

 

§11.302(d)(1)(viii) Operating Feasibility: Achievable Affordable Rents- Added Achievable Affordable Rent to the section.

 

§11.302(i)(1) Feasibility Conclusion: Added new language and chart for Capture Rates.

 

§11.303(c)(1) Market Analyst Qualifications: Replaced language to 24 months for Market Analysis submission window. Added clarifying language to October 1st of the second year following the analyst’s most recent submission.

 

§11.303(d)(10)(B) Market Analysis Contents- Added Achievable Affordable Rent to the section.

 

§11.303(d)(10)(B)(vi) Market Analysis Contents- Added Achievable Affordable Rent to the section.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter E

§11.901(2) Refund of Competitive HTC Pre-Application Fees- Added language that after February 1 the Department will not issue a refund for Pre-Application fees.

 

10 TAC Chapter 11, Subchapter F

No major changes to the QAP in this subchapter.

 

Attachment 1: Preamble, including required analysis, for proposed repeal of 10 TAC Chapter 11, Qualified Allocation Plan

The Texas Department of Housing and Community (the Department) proposes the repeal of 10 TAC Chapter 11, Qualified Allocation Plan (QAP). The purpose of the proposed repeal is to eliminate an outdated rule while adopting a new updated rule under separate action.

The Department has analyzed this proposed rulemaking and the analysis is described below for each category of analysis performed.

a. GOVERNMENT GROWTH IMPACT STATEMENT REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.0221.

1.                     Mr. Bobby Wilkinson, Executive Director, has determined that, for the first five years the proposed repeal would be in effect, the proposed repeal does not create or eliminate a government program, but relates to the repeal, and simultaneous readoption making changes to an existing activity, concerning the allocation of Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC).

2.                     The proposed repeal does not require a change in work that would require the creation of new employee positions, nor is the proposed repeal significant enough to reduce work load to a degree that any existing employee positions are eliminated.

3.                     The proposed repeal does not require additional future legislative appropriations.

4.                     The proposed repeal does not result in an increase in fees paid to the Department or in a decrease in fees paid to the Department.

5.                     The proposed repeal is not creating a new regulation, except that it is being replaced by a new rule simultaneously to provide for revisions.

6.                     The proposed action will repeal an existing regulation, but is associated with a simultaneous adoption of the subchapters in 10 TAC Chapter 11, the Qualified Allocation Plan, in order to better address the requirements of Tex. Gov’t Code Ch. 2306, Subchapter DD.

7.                     The proposed repeal will not increase or decrease the number of individuals subject to the rule’s applicability.

8.                     The proposed repeal will not negatively or positively affect this state’s economy.

b. ADVERSE ECONOMIC IMPACT ON SMALL OR MICRO-BUSINESS OR RURAL COMMUNITIES AND REUGLATORY FLEXIBILITY REQUIRED BY TEX. GOV’T CODE §2006.002.

The Department has evaluated this proposed repeal and determined that the proposed repeal will not create an economic effect on small or micro-businesses or rural communities.

c. TAKINGS IMPACT ASSESSMENT REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2007.043.

The proposed repeal does not contemplate or authorize a takings by the Department; therefore, no Takins Impact Assessment is required.

d. LOCAL EMPLOYMENT IMPACT STATEMENTS REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(6).

The Department has evaluated the proposed repeal would be in effect there would be no economic effect on local employment; therefore no local employment impact statement is required to be prepared for the rule.

e. PUBLIC BENEFIT/COST NOTE REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(5).Mr. Wilkinson has also determined that, for each year of the first five years the proposed repeal is in effect, the public benefit anticipated as a result of the repealed section would be an updated and more germane rule for administering the allocation of LIHTC. There will not be economic costs to individuals required to comply with the repealed section.

f. FISCAL NOTE REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(4).

Mr. Wilkinson has determined that for each year of the first give years the proposed repeal is in effect, enforcing or administering the repeal does not have any foreseeable implications related to costs or revenues of the state or local governments.

SUMMARY OF PUBLIC COMMENT. The public comment period was held from September 18, 2026 and October 9, 2026, to receive stakeholder comment on the repealed section.

STATUTORY AUTHORITY. The proposed repeal is made to pursuant to Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.053, which authorizes the Department to adopt rules. Except as described herein the proposed repealed sections affect no other code, article, or statute.

10 TAC Chapter 11, Qualified Allocation Plan

SUBCHAPTER A

§11.1 General

§11.2 Program Calendar for Housing Tax Credits

§11.3 Housing De-Concentration Factors

§11.4 Tax Credit Request and Award Limits

§11.5 Competitive HTC Set-Asides. (§2306.111(d))

§11.6 Competitive HTC Allocation Process

§11.7 Tie Breaker Factors

§11.8 Pre-Application Requirements (Competitive HTC Only)

§11.9 Competitive HTC Selection Criteria

§11.10 Third Party Request for Administrative Deficiency for Competitive HTC Applications

SUBCHAPTER B

§11.101 Site and Development Requirements and Restrictions

SUBCHAPTER C

§11.201 Procedural Requirements for Application Submission

§11.202 Ineligible Applicants and Applications

§11.203 Public Notifications (§2306.6705(9))

§11.204 Required Documentation for Application Submission

§11.205 Required Third Party Reports

§11.206 Board Decisions (§§2306.6725(c); 2306.6731; and 42(m)(1)(A)(iv))

§11.207 Waiver of Rules

SUBCHAPTER D

§11.301 General Provisions

§11.302 Underwriting Rules and Guidelines

§11.303 Markey Analysis Rules and Guidelines

§11.304 Appraisal Rules and Guidelines

§11.305 Environmental Site Assessment Rules and Guidelines

§11.306 Property Condition Assessment Guidelines

SUBCHAPTER E

§11.901 Fee Schedule

§11.902 Appeals Process

§11.903 Adherence to Obligations

§11.904 Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Policy

§11.905 General Information for Commitments or Determination Notices

§11.906 Commitment and Determination Notice General Requirements and Required Documentation

§11.907 Carryover Agreement General Requirements and Required Documentation

SUBCHAPTER F

§11.1001 General

§11.1002 Program Calendar for State Housing Tax Credits Associated with Competitive HTC Applications

§11.1003 Set-Aside for Previously Awarded Developments for Competitive HTC Applications

§11.1004 Procedural Requirements for Requests for State Housing Tax Credits Associated with Competitive HTC Applications

§11.1005 Required Documentation for State Housing Tax Credit Request Submission Associated with Competitive HTC Applications

§11.1006 State Housing Tax Credits Underwriting and Loan Policy Associated with Competitive HTC

§11.1007 State Housing Tax Credits Selection Criteria Associated with Competitive HTC Applications

§11.1008 State Housing Tax Credits for Tax-Exempt Bond Developments

Attachment 2 Preamble, including required analysis, for proposed new 10 TAC Chapter 11, Qualified Allocation Plan

The Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs (the “Department”) proposes new 10 TAC Chapter 11, Qualified Allocation Plan (QAP). The purpose of the proposed new section is to provide compliance with Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.67022 and to update the rule to: add new definitions; clarify multiple definitions; update the Program Calendar; modify requirements for grocery store tiebreaker eligibility; add Pharmacies and Urgent Cares as a new tiebreaker; update Mandatory Amenity Requirements; require Development Staff to provide a 45-day notice to tenants for changes in supportive services; and to significantly reduce the reduce wordcount for readability.

Tex. Gov’t Code §2001.0045(b) does not apply to the rule proposed for action for two reasons: 1) the state’s adoption of the QAP is necessary to comply with IRC §42; and 2) the state’s adoption of the QAP is necessary to comply with Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.67022. The Department has analyzed this proposed rulemaking and the analysis is described below for each category of analysis performed.

a. GOVERNMENT GROWTH IMPACT STATEMENT REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.0221.

Mr. Bobby Wilkinson, Executive Director, has determined that, for the first five years the proposed new rule would be in effect:

1. The proposed rule does not create or eliminate a government program, but relates to the readoption of this rule which makes changes to an existing activity, concerning the allocation of Low Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC).

2. The proposed new rule does not require a change in work that would require the creation of new employee positions, nor are the rule changes significant enough to reduce work load to a degree that eliminates any existing employee positions.

3. The proposed rule changes do not require additional future legislative appropriations.

4. The rule changes will not result in any increases or decreases in fees.

5. The proposed rule is not creating a new regulation, except that it is replacing a rule being repealed simultaneously to provide for revisions.

6. The proposed rule will not limit or repeal an existing regulation, but can be considered to “expand” the existing regulations on this activity because the proposed rule has sought to clarify Application requirements.

Some “expansions” are offset by corresponding “contractions” in the rules, compared to the 2026 QAP. Notably, the Department has sought to remove superfluous language wherever possible and to consolidate rules to reflect current process. These additions, removals, and revisions to the QAP are necessary to ensure compliance with IRC

§42 and Tex. Gov’t Code §2306.67022, among other federal and state requirements.

7. The proposed rule will not increase or decrease the number of individuals subject to the rule’s applicability; and

8. The proposed rule will not negatively affect the state’s economy, and may be considered to have a positive effect on the state’s economy because changes at 10 TAC §11.9(c)(7), Proximity to Job Areas, may help to encourage the Development of affordable multifamily housing in robust markets with strong and growing economies.

b. ADVERSE ECONOMIC IMPACT ON SMALL OR MICRO-BUSINESSES OR RURAL COMMUNITIES AND REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2006.002. The Department, in drafting this proposed rule, has attempted to reduce any adverse economic effect on small or micro-business or rural communities while remaining consistent with the statutory requirements of Tex. Gov’t Code  §2306.67022. Some stakeholders have reported that their average cost of filing an Application is between $50,000 and $60,000, which may vary depending on the specific type of Application, location of the Development Site, and other non-state of Texas funding sources utilized. The proposed rules do not, on average, result in an increased cost of filing an application as compared to existing program rules.

1. The Department has evaluated this rule and determined that none of the adverse effect strategies outlined in Tex. Gov’t Code §2006.002(b) are applicable.

2. There are approximately 100 to 150 small or micro-businesses subject to the proposed rule for which the economic impact of the rule may range from $480 to many thousands of dollars, just to submit an Application for Competitive or non-Competitive HTCs. The Department bases this estimate on the potential number of Applicants and their related parties who may submit applications to TDHCA for LIHTC. The fee for submitting an Application for LIHTC is $30 per unit, and all Applicants are required to propose constructing, at a minimum, 16 Units. While, in theory, there is no limit to the number of Units that could be proposed in a single Application, practically speaking, the Department sees few proposed Developments larger than 350 Units, which, by way of example, would carry a fee schedule of $10,500. These Application Fee costs are not inclusive of external costs required by the basic business necessities underlying any real estate transaction, from placing earnest money on land, conducting an Environmental Site Assessment, conducting a market study, potentially retaining counsel, hiring an architect and an engineer to construct basic site designs and elevations, and paying any other related, third-party fees for securing the necessary financing to construct multifamily housing. Nor does this estimate include fees from the Department for Applications that successfully attain an award.

There are 1,376 rural communities potentially subject to the proposed rule for which the economic impact of the rule is projected to be $0. The proposed rule places no financial burdens on rural communities, as the costs associated with submitting an Application are born entirely by private parties. If anything, a rural community securing a LIHTC Development will experience an economic benefit, not least among which is the potential increased property tax revenue from a large multifamily Development.

3. The Department has determined that because there are rural tax credit awardees, this program helps promote construction activities and long term tax base in rural areas of Texas. Aside from the fees and costs associated with submitting an Application, there is a probable positive economic effect on small or micro-businesses or rural communities that receive LIHTC awards and successfully use those awards to construct multifamily housing, although the specific impact is not able to be quantified in advance

c. TAKINGS IMPACT ASSESSMENT REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2007.043.                     The proposed rule does not contemplate or authorize a takings by the Department. Therefore, no Takings Impact Assessment is required.

d. LOCAL EMPLOYMENT IMPACT STATEMENTS REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(6).

The Department has evaluated the rule as to its possible effects on local economies and has determined that for the first five years the rule will be in effect the proposed rule may provide a possible positive economic effect on local employment in association with this rule since LIHTC Developments often involve a total input of, typically at a minimum, $5 million in capital, but often an input of $10 million - $30 million. Such a capital investment has concrete direct, indirect, and induced effects on the local and regional economies. However, because the exact location of where program funds and development are directed is not determined in rule, there is no way to determine during rulemaking where the positive effects may occur. Furthermore, while the Department knows that any and all impacts are positive, that impact is not able to be quantified for any given community until a proposed Development is actually awarded LIHTC, given the unique characteristics of each proposed multifamily Development and region in which it is being developed. Texas Gov’t Code §2001.022(a) states that this “impact statement must describe in detail the probable effect of the rule on employment in each geographic region affected by this rule…” Considering that significant construction activity is associated with any LIHTC Development and that each apartment community significantly increases the property value of the land being developed, there are no probable negative effects of the new rule on particular geographic regions. If anything, positive effects will ensue in those communities where developers receive LIHTC awards.

e. PUBLIC BENEFIT/COST NOTE REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(5). Mr. Wilkinson has determined that, for each year of the first five years the new section is in effect, the public benefit anticipated as a result of the new section will be an updated and more germane rule for administering the allocation of LIHTC with considerations made for applicants as it relates to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the application process. Other than the fees mentioned in section a4 above, there is no change to the economic cost to any individuals required to comply with the new section because the same processes described by the rule have already been in place through the rule found at this section being repealed. The average cost of filing an application remains between $50,000 and $60,000, which may vary depending on the specific type of application, location of the development site, and other non-state of Texas funding sources utilized. The proposed rules do not, on average, result in an increased cost of filing an application as compared to the existing program rules.

f. FISCAL NOTE REQUIRED BY TEX GOV’T CODE §2001.024(a)(4). Mr. Wilkinson also has determined that for each year of the first five years the new section is in effect, enforcing or administering the new section does not have any foreseeable implications related to costs or revenues of the state or local governments because the same processes described by the rule have already been in place through the rule found at this section being repealed. If anything, Departmental revenues may increase due to a comparatively higher volume of Applications, which slightly increases the amount of fees TDHCA receives.

SUMMARY OF PUBLIC COMMENT. The public comment period was held September 18, 2026, to October 9, 2026, to receive public comment on the proposed new sections of rule. Comment was received from 41 commenters, and a summary of these comments and the Department’s reasoned response is included with the Board Item.

STATUTORY AUTHORITY. The adoption of these sections of rule is made pursuant to Tex. Gov’t Code §§2306.053 and 2306.67022, which authorize the Department to adopt rules and, specifically, this Qualified Allocation Plan.  Except as described herein the repealed sections affect no other code, article, or statute.  The rule proposed for adoption by the Board has been reviewed by legal counsel and found to be a valid exercise of the Department’s legal authority.

2027 QAP DRAFT PUBLIC COMMENT SUMMARY

SUMMARY OF PUBLIC COMMENT. The public comment period was held September 18, 2026, to October 9, 2026, to receive stakeholders comment on the new proposed sections. Comment was received from 41 commenters as listed below:

(1) Urbanize, Inc, (2) City of San Antonio Housing, (3) Lonestar Development Partners, (4) L + M Development Partners, (5) KCG Companies, (6) Houston Department of Transformation, (7) Javelin Development, (8) LeadingAge Texas, (9) Sallie Burchett, (10) Catalyst Development, (11) JCM Ventures, (12) Fred C. Merrill, (13) Newport Partners, (14) Sarah Andre, (15) Disability Rights Texas, (16) ACEEE, (17) Purple Martin Real Estate, (18) CenterPoint Energy, (19) Lorena Ramirez, (20) Coalition of Texans with Disabilities, (21) SPEER, (22) Sierra Club, (23) ARX Advantage, (24) IREM, (25) TAAHP, (26) Housing Alliance HTX, (27) Titanium Housing, (28) JES Holdings, (29) Texas Housers, (30) Wallace Reed, (31) RDNS Consulting, (32) RRHA, (33) AARP Texas, (34) Foundation Communities, (35) ITEX, (36) State Representative Erin Zwiener, (37) S Anderson Consulting, (38) Brinshore Development, (39) State Representative Jessica Gonzalez, (40) FILO Policy, and (41) State Senator Borris Miles.

It should be noted that in interest of brevity, some of the more extensive comments received have been summarized significantly; however, copies of all comments received have the commenters’ number denoted and are all available on the Department Website.

§11.1(d)(1).  Definition: Achievable Affordable Rent

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 35 believes this rule should not be implemented because it relies on market conditions at the time of application, which may not accurately reflect conditions when the property closes, develops, and leases up. Commenter 35 says this approach could constrain underwriting assumptions and jeopardize feasibility. 

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 35’s concern regarding the use of Achievable Affordable Rent based on market conditions at the time of application. Underwriting assumptions are necessarily based on the market conditions and information available at the time of application and review, including market rents, maximum program rents, operating expenses, and other underwriting assumptions.

Staff believes the Achievable Affordable Rent requirement is necessary because there are multiple markets across the state where comparable affordable properties are not currently achieving maximum program rents. Underwriting a Development to rents that are not supported by current market conditions may overstate revenue and negatively affect long-term feasibility.

The rules allow the underwritten rent to be the lesser of the maximum program rent or an amount up to 10% above the Achievable Affordable Rent. Staff believes this provides reasonable flexibility for changing market conditions while ensuring that underwriting assumptions remain supported by current market data.

§11.1(d)(85). Definition: Person or Persons with Disabilities

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 34 requests removal of the “record of impairment” requirement in the definition of Person or Persons with Disabilities. Commenter 34 states it may create barriers for individuals with disabilities and raises fair housing concerns. Commenter 34 states that although a record of impairment is only one of several ways to meet the definition, they encourage TDHCA to revise the definition.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates this comment but does not recommend any changes as the “record of impairment” is an optional, but not mandatory, means of meeting the requirement of the rule.  Additionally, this is one of the ways a person meets the definition of disability under the Fair Housing Act.

§11.1(d)(121) (Formerly). Definition: Single Room Occupancy

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 34 recommends that staff reinstate this definition since it establishes housing for a specific type of population that should be differentiated from family housing and other forms of supportive housing. Commenter 34 believes maintaining a clear definition for this would help preserve this distinction and ensure that the QAP appropriately recognizes the unique characteristics and intended population of these developments.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 34’s suggestion and has made a change in response to this request.

§11.1(d)(130) (Formerly). Definition: Operating Expenses Database

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 17, 25 and 38 requests the definition of “Operating Expenses Database” be reinstated for the 2027 QAP. Commenter 17 states that this definition is an important part of the Underwriting process. Commenters 25 and 38 state that this is because the proposed rule still relies on the “Departments database” for expense data.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 25, and 38’s request to reinstate the definition of “Operating Expenses Database.” Upon further review, Staff agrees that the definition provides useful clarification because the proposed rules continue to reference the Department’s database for operating expense information. Staff has made a responsive change to restore the definition.

§11.1(k) and §§11.101(b)(4)(O) and (b)(8)(C): References to Relevant Accessibility and Fair Housing Laws

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 15, 20, 29 and 33 have concerns regarding the removal of language referencing accessibility and fair housing laws throughout the rule during the copy-editing process. Commenters 15, 20, 29 and 33 believe that people reviewing this document may not be familiar with all these laws, and their inclusion in the rule serves a purpose. Commenters 15, 20, 29 and 33 request these references be restored and have provided such language.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates these comments and the requested language has been added back into the QAP.

§11.2(a). Competitive HTC Deadlines

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 requests that the End of Application Acceptance Period be March 1, 2027 rather than February 26, 2027. Commenter 17 states that historically, the 9% application due date is March 1, except when March 1 falls on a weekend.

Commenter 35 believes the pre-application submission window is late in this year’s QAP and believes this would condense the window for the final Full Application deadline. Commenter 35 believes moving this window earlier in the month will give all applicants more time to complete these steps.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17 and 35’s concerns regarding the Application Acceptance Period and the shortened window it may give for applicants. Setting appropriate deadlines within the QAP requires balancing the needs of the development community with the Department’s processes. Having the applications be due one day earlier than the statutory deadline allows for the Department to address any last-minute system issues that may arise without creating a legal predicament. Similarly, having a brief buffer of a few days after the holidays allows staff to address any issues that arise with the online pre-application form. Staff recommends no change.

§11.2(b). Resolutions Delivery Date

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 requests the words “Resolution Delivery Date” be added back to this section. Commenter 17 states this term is referred to in other parts of the QAP, but the actual term has been stricken from this section, where it should be defined.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s comment on this item and has made a responsive change to this extent.

§11.6(3)(C)(iv). High-Quality Pre-K

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 31 and 37 believe the change in this rule to require a written agreement with an educational provider gives advantage to those developers who have done HQ Pre-Ks before and will ultimately decrease the number of Applications that come with a HQ Pre-K. Additionally, Commenters 31 and 37 state the QAP already provides a framework for dealing with Applications that fail to deliver scoring dependent items and that this change won't prevent agreements that are rescinded.

Commenter 34 requests that staff allow Supportive Housing Developments in which at least 70% of the units contain multiple bedrooms to qualify for this HQ Pre-K priority. Commenter 34 believes Developments with a substantial proportion of multiple-bedroom units are well suited to serving families with children and specifies that this change would recognize that supportive housing can serve families with children.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 31 and 37’s concerns regarding the advantage developers with previous HQ Pre-K experience have when navigating the additional rules provided in this section. While staff understands this dynamic may create an additional measure needed for application submission, this requirement seems necessary to ensure that those who select this item have a shared understanding with the proposed educational provider to ensure these spaces are successfully implemented.

Staff acknowledges Commenter 34’s suggestion to allow Supportive Housing developments to be eligible for the HQ Pre-K priority in the QAP. Staff appreciates the arguments provided by Commenter 34 and would encourage them to bring this topic up for further discussion at the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.7(2) Tie Breaker Factors

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 3 does not support adding pharmacies and urgent care centers to the list of tie breakers and suggests staff revisit those amenities during the following QAP cycle.  Additionally, Commenter 3 believes that adding so many factors to the tie breaker without understanding their impact would not be wise given the unknown implications of how these changes will impact site selection.

Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10 and 35 ask that staff weigh the practical consequences of significant tie breaker changes at this stage of the cycle as it can create a burden for developers in their site selection process. With this, Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10 and 35 encourage changes to the tie breaker only where they produce a meaningful resident or programmatic outcome. Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10 and 35 ask staff to avoid unnecessary changes after site selection has begun.

Commenter 29 believes there should be a Tie Breaker that incentivizes the lowest income units, which are of the highest need in the state. Commenter 29 specifies that replacing the linear distance tie breaker at §11.7(2) with this weighted tie breaker formula preserves an incentive for more total affordable units while further incentivizing the most badly needed units, those that are affordable to the lowest income households.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates all comments received on the tie-breaker and recognizes that this topic is highly consequential. Specific comments related to individual tie-breaker features are addressed in the following paragraphs.

§11.7(2)(A)(i). Tie Breaker Factors, Parks

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 7 and 28 applaud the restriction against using any school property as a park as well as the requirement for clear markings such as a trail.

Commenter 31 believes the sentence “bird watching areas, community gardens, or natural retreats” should be added back in and the requirements of “clear signage and established hiking or walking trails” should be removed. Commenter 31 believes that the removed language had benefits for older residents and the added language is contrary to how wilderness areas exist in cities. Commenter 31 has provided revised language that they believe will better achieve the goal of preventing green spaces with no actual recreational purpose being used for this tie breaker.

Commenter 37 does not believe the language change addresses the issue of random green spaces with no actual recreational purpose being used for this tie breaker. Commenter 37 has provided revised language for this item to better include what the Department is looking for.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff has made changes to the definition of “parks” to clarify where the required signage may be located and is optimistic that the revised rule will result in high quality parks being used for the tie-breaker.

§11.7(2)(A)(iii). Tie Breaker Factors, Grocery stores

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 3 supports removing the fresh fish requirement from the grocery store tie breaker.

Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 14 support the new language confirming that grocery stores requiring a paid membership can qualify. Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 14 believe this type of grocery resource is still a benefit for a community and that the required fee is made up through the discounts given on products.

Commenters 7, 15, 28, 29 and 35 oppose the new language allowing membership grocery stores to count for this tie breaker. Commenters 7, 29 and 35 explain that these grocery stores are generally geared towards larger, more affluent families and not seniors and low-income persons who don’t often shop in this manner.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff does not recommend any changes based on these comments. While the Department recognizes that the cost of an annual grocery store membership is a small barrier of entry, staff agrees with commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 14 that these stores still provide a benefit.

§11.7(2)(A)(v). Tie Breaker Factors, Pharmacies

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14 and 35 support the proposed language allowing a qualifying pharmacy inside a grocery store to count as its own feature, even when that grocery store is also counted. Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14 and 35 believe the outcome of this change is best for residents who can get more out of nearby amenities. Commenters 7 and 28 believe that grocery stores with pharmacies inside generally have larger and more robust offerings. Commenter 35 speaks to the benefits for elderly residents, persons with disabilities or mobility limitations, and households with limited transportation options.

Commenters 7 and 28 say adding Pharmacies is ideal since they serve all ages and situations.

Commenter 29 recommends targeting the proposed incentive for properties near pharmacies to just pharmacies that have a licensed nurse employed onsite. Commenter 29 specifies that these pharmacies provide basic healthcare or clinical services beyond just being a pharmacy and that many pharmacies provide free delivery services.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff agrees that pharmacies located inside of grocery stores provide a meaningful benefit to residents and recommends that this language remains unchanged. Additional changes related to this tie-breaker have been made and are addressed in the next item.

§11.7(2)(A)(vi). Tie Breaker Factors, Urgent care clinic

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Comments for this topic are split into Support and Opposition given the number of comments received.

Support

Commenter 8 supports the addition of the urgent care tie breaker as it is a more valuable amenity for older Texans as it will give them more options to address medical needs.

Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 20, 29, 33 and 35 support keeping Urgent care clinics as an eligible tie-breaker feature. Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 20, 30 and 35 recommend removing the extended service hours requirement as this would disqualify some clinics who operate at different hours but otherwise provide the desired services. Commenters 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14 and 35 believe verifying business hours may be difficult and will create an administrative burden for applicants and businesses to confirm.

Commenter 1 asserts that the qualifying language “serve all clients regardless of age” will have a practical effect of disallowing pediatric urgent cares. Commenter 1 does not believe this exclusion is the intent of the rule and believes child-serving amenities are already covered in the tie breaker. Commenter 1 has provided suggested language to address this issue.

Commenters 17 and 30 suggest adding additional language to include emergency medical facilities and hospital emergency rooms as part of the Tie Breaker for urgent cares.

Commenter 20 supports the use of urgent cares in the tie breaker and has provided revised language to that extent. Commenters 20 and 29 believe Urgent cares are valuable because they operate outside of regular business hours, both during weekdays and weekends, allow disabled and low income tenants the flexibility for non-emergent health issues to be treated, without having to miss hours of work, and potentially lose pay, as a result.

Commenter 27 believes the rules for Urgent cares are narrowly defined such that emergency medical facilities that would be valuable to potential tenants are excluded. Specifically, “treatment of acute and chronic illness and injury” as well as meeting the operational hours, client and radiology requirements. Commenter 27 has provided revised language.

Commenter 29 specifies that Primary Care Physicians (PCP) have additional barriers to access and being near an Urgent care facilities can help fill a specific gap in healthcare service availability.

Commenter 30 believes the exclusion of freestanding emergency medical care facilities and general hospitals should be removed because there is no policy basis for a feature that credits a clinic open 10 hours a day while disqualifying the hospital next door. Additionally, Commenter 30 finds conflicting rules related to qualifying health-related facilities in other parts of the QAP and believes there is Target Population-specific benefits that Urgent cares will provide. Commenter 30 has provided a technical correction and suggested language reflecting their suggestions in the comment.

Commenter 33 has provided a definition or Urgent care that they assert uses verifiable characteristics to identify urgent care clinics while excluding freestanding emergency rooms and hospital emergency departments. Commenter 33 believes this tie breaker is important for providing convenient, affordable and high-quality services to residents.

Opposition

Commenters 7 and 28 acknowledge the importance of Urgent cares for residents but do not think it should be included in the tie breaker list. Commenters 7 and 28 explain how Urgent cares are used far less than the other tie breaker feature and warns that this item will be difficult to review for staff given there is no definitive list.

Commenters 31 and 37 oppose the inclusion of Urgent cares as a tie breaker because it unfairly benefits larger municipalities, the data is difficult to obtain, and the definition is too strict. Commenters 31 and 37 believes this tie breaker needs more research done before it is included permanently in the QAP.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates the robust discussion on this item and recognizes that there are many factors of urgent care facilities that must be considered when creating policy. In response to these changes and the comments submitted regarding pharmacies, staff recommends combining these two types of facilities into a single amenity for the tie breaker and allowing applicants to choose one or the other. Responsive edits have been made to the proposed QAP.

§11.7(2)(D) Tie Breaker, Replacement of Features

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Comment 17 suggests adding clarifying language to Replacement of Features section of the Tiebreakers. Commenter 17 states this revision might be necessary to address the possibility that up to three features can be disqualified prior to the proximity to features tie breaker being invalid.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17s suggestion and has made a responsive change to this extent.

§11.8, §11.9 and §11.203: Low-Income Renter Engagement in the Application Process

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 29 recommends incentivizing properties with existing resident and tenant organizations. Commenter 29 has provided suggested revisions to numerous sections to increase opportunities for low-income tenant (and potential tenant) input on specific applications.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 29’s efforts to suggest implementations that can increase tenant engagement in the application process. Since this comment is regarding sections that have not been adjusted yet this year, we suggest bringing this concept up at the 2028 QAP Roundtables for further discussion with staff and stakeholders.

§11.9(b)(2)(C). Sponsor Characteristics - Property Tax Status

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 states that this rule incentivizing developers to forego tax exemptions will not decrease the cost of housing but rather increase the financing gaps that already exist in projects. Commenter 2 suggests not penalizing developments from utilizing a tax exemption if the municipality grants it.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff understands the concerns from Commenter 2 regarding the Sponsor Characteristics option related to properties paying property taxes. Staff believes this option helps balance the need for property tax relief while also acknowledging the important function those taxes have for local governments. Staff encourages Commenter 2 to bring this item up for further discussion at the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.9(c)(4)(A). Section 811 Project Rental Assistance

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 27 suggests that the number of Section 811 units provided to qualify for points should not exceed 5% of the total number of units in that subject application, regardless of whether the 811 units will ultimately be placed in the subject development, or in an existing development within the applicant team’s portfolio.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges the consistency and coherence of this alternative method for calculating required units. Staff does not believe it is appropriate to make a responsive change at this time, as it would necessarily result in a decrease in committed 811 units in the 2027 round.

§11.9(c)(4)(B) & (C) Persons with Special Housing Needs

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 states it would be helpful for this section to explicitly list who qualifies, as previously stated in the 2026 QAP.

Commenters 23 and 32 state that this subsection has not worked in rural areas for the last years and should only be applicable to urban areas with ample service providers. Commenters 23 and 32 ask that USDA and At-Risk be exempt from these points. If exemption is not an option, they ask that Continuum of Care providers be required to disclose to TDHCA a full list of the areas that they cover, and that this list should appear in the application materials provided by TDHCA.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s perspective but does not recommend any changes.  The revised language refers back to a definition found earlier in the QAP that includes the desired information.

The Department recognizes that rural housing providers have had challenges in identifying appropriate Continuum of Care organizations.  Unfortunately, TDHCA does not have authority to require Continuum of Care providers to disclose their area of operation and cannot adopt this recommendation.

§11.9(c)(7)(A). Proximity to Jobs

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 opposes the radius being at 5 miles for this item as it would negate the intent of the scoring item. Commenter 2 believes that restricting the radius to 1 mile is more beneficial to residents as it would represent a more realistic distance families would travel to access such amenities.

Commenter 17 suggests a revision to reflect that On the Map doesn’t create GPS coordinates but does provide the functionality to create the required report.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 2’s comment regarding the appropriate radius for providing the best service to residents. We encourage you to bring this item up during the 2028 QAP Roundtable discussions. 

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s concern regarding clarity of the requirement but maintain that the language as written is clear and does not warrant a change.

§11.9(d)(1). Criteria promoting community support and engagement

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 6 and 19 have raised concerns regarding the rules related to support from elected officials and local community members. Commenters 6 and 19 believe elected officials should be required to gain approval from the community prior to providing a letter of support for the project. Commenter 19 believes opposition from residents living immediately adjacent to a proposed development should be formally acknowledged and meaningfully evaluated.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff understands Commenter 6 and 19’s concerns regarding the community support and engagement rules and the way feedback is received and implemented by the Department. In relation to these rules and the QAP, the Department is subject to Tex. Gov’t Code §2306 and adjusting these statutes would require involvement from the Texas Legislature.

§11.9(d)(2). Commitment of Development Funding by LPS

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 suggests reverting back to the 2026 QAP description of the LPS “with jurisdiction over the proposed Development” rather than using “relevant” LPS.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s suggestions for this item and has made a change in response.

§11.9(e)(6). Historic Preservation

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 7 believes the point advantage for Historic projects is unnecessary. Commenter 7 cites concerns related to the location, development size, and incentives available to historic projects.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 7’s concerns regarding the point advantage for Historic projects. Staff feels this advantage is warranted given the complexity of these deals and would suggest raising this issue for further discussion during the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.9(c) and §§11.101(a)(1) and (b)(6): Reduce Tenant Vulnerability to Hazards

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 29 calls on the Department to provide incentives that would increase the resilience of individual properties in the event of issues like power outages following severe weather. Commenter 29 states they have advocated for generators and onsite power generation and argues the Department should ensure subsidized housing is resilient against flooding helps protect low income tenants and support them through recovery while reducing flood insurance costs for developers. Commenter 29 has provided recommended language changes.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 29 for their concern regarding resiliency against various natural disasters and the costs associated with ensuring resident safety in these developments.  Staff shares these concerns and recognizes the greater impact this can have for vulnerable populations. Staff encourages Commenter 29 to further explore these ideas with the LIHTC development community and bring them up for discussion at the 2028 QAP Roundtable discussions.

§11.101(a)(2)(E). Undesirable Site Features

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 suggests adding back the dates which various assistance types must be in place, that way applicants can determine if their development meets the exemption requirement.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 17 request to bring the dates back of various assistance types. Staff has made a responsive change.

§11.101(a)(2)(E). Undesirable Site Features

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 supports this change allowing for HUD siting requirements as evidence of sufficient mitigation.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 2’s support for this item.

§11.101(a)(3)(C). Neighborhood Risk Factors

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17, 25, 26, 27 and 38 requests that Reconstruction applications with ongoing and existing federal assistance be exempt from Violent Crime NRFs.

Commenters 25, 26 and 38 believe this rule as written will adversely impact the lives of existing residents of federally funded redevelopments, particularly HUD Choice Neighborhoods and RAD conversion projects, in the neighborhoods they are designed to renew with mixed income housing opportunities. Commenters 17, 25, 26, 27 and 38 request that the Department reinstate language clarifying the policy related to Reconstruction and has provided a suggested revision to this extent. Commenters 17, 26 and 27 specified that it is important to remove barriers to the improvement or replacement of existing housing that already receives state or federal assistance.

Commenter 29 supports staff’s decision to maintain the use of neighborhoodscout.com data for determining crime levels despite other recommendations designed to allow additional data sources. Commenter 29 agrees with concerns about relying on a single commercial source but states they advocate for this methodology as generally more suitable for a competition based on comparison between applicants.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 25, 26, 27, and 38’s request to exempt Reconstruction applications from the Violent Crime Neighborhood Risk Factor. Staff believes that Reconstruction warrants a higher standard as the construction type offers the flexibility to change the development site, thereby eliminating the need for an exemption from this rule. Staff would also like to provide additional opportunity to offer input on this issue and recommends bringing it forward for further discussion during the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

Staff appreciates Commenter 29’s support on the data methodology language for this item.

§11.101(b)(1)(A)(viii). Rehabilitation Developments - Re-Syndication

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 35 recommends allowing a Rehabilitation application to be submitted as soon as the end of the compliance period, as allowed by the IRS. Commenter 35 says this is important for At-risk developments, rural properties, and those with less than 150 units in need of greater capital.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 35’s concerns related to the time Developments must wait before they can be submitted as a Rehabilitation application. Staff understands the difficulty this may put some properties in, especially those mentioned in the comment, but believes the intention of this item is to ensure the most efficient use of limited 9% Tax Credit. Staff recommends bringing this item up for discussion during the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.101(b)(1)(A)(xi). Ineligible Developments

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 supports removing the requirement for rehabilitation projects and those with existing federal assistance from HUD, USDA, or VA, and Developments encumbered by a TDHCA LURA from needing to acquire a 40% poverty rate waiver. Commenter 2 believes this will help ensure stability and upgraded living conditions for people who have a hard time finding similar housing.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 2’s remarks on this item.

§11.101(b)(4)(L) and §11.101(b)(6)(B)(iii)(IX). Heat Pumps

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Support

Commenters 16, 18, 21, 22, 36 and 41 support the language for a Unit to have heating provided by a heat pump or natural gas.  Commenters 16, 18, 21, 22, 25, 36 and 41 cite that this technology will help lower winter peak demand on the energy grid and reduce energy costs for residents.

Commenter 36 supports this item and cites recent storm-related disasters as to the importance of responsibly managing the power-grid through energy efficiency improvements in affordable housing. Commenter 36 also cites cost-savings as an important aspect to the use of a heat pump system and how these savings are very important for those who will call this housing home.

Commenters 21 and 22 oppose the inclusion of a heat pump related rules in Section (6)(C)(iii)(IX) of this subsection, believing that it will be more impactful as a Mandatory Development Amenity. Commenters 21 and 22 have provided revised language that they believe with help reduce confusion relating to the air conditioning requirements.

Commenter 22 has provided revised language for Section (6)(C)(iii)(IX) that would create an incentive for a higher standard of electric heat pump system, if staff were to keep both references in the rule.

Opposition

Commenters 17, 23, 32, 34 and 38 oppose this language and request to remove Heat Pumps from the list of Mandatory Development Amenities. Commenters 17, 23, 25, 32, 34 and 38 do not believe specific heating/cooling systems should not be mandated and could conflict with local and state regulations. Commenter 23 does not believe the energy savings will necessarily pass down to the resident and may increase the rental rate charged for the unit. Commenter 32 believes this mandate appears to be inconsistent with the TREO review which required the elimination of unnecessary regulation.

Commenters 17, 25, 27, 34 and 38 request that the Department adopt the 1.5-point heat pump amenity incentive in place of setting it as threshold. Commenters 17, 25, 27, 34 and 38 appreciate staff's efforts to increase energy efficiency across the affordable housing market but believes a threshold requirement for HVAC limits design flexibility, increases costs, and establishes additional market demand on a single HVAC technology.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates all of the comments on this item and recognizes that a change in required equipment and systems must be carefully considered. Having reviewed all comments and taken into consideration the benefits of moving to heat pump systems, staff recommends that they remain in the QAP as a threshold requirement. Projects that cannot comply with this requirement would be able to request a waiver in accordance with the procedures outlined in the rule.

§11.101(b)(5). Common Amenities

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 suggests adding revised language to clarify that only if package lockers are provided (as opposed to a package room), one locker is required for every eight units.

Commenter 29 recommends considering an incentive to ease the disproportionate burden that pet restrictions and fees have on low-income tenants. Commenter 29 says properties that benefit from pet amenities in the QAP should not be able to implement restrictive policies that create a barrier for low-income tenants with pets.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s language revision suggestion but feels the language as written is clear for the intent of the item.

Staff appreciates Commenter 29’s suggestion to introduce rules that would help ease the burden pet restrictions and fees have on tenants but does not recommend any changes to the QAP in response.

§11.101(b)(5)(C)(i)(I)(b). Educational Provider Agreement

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 believes this requirement should be revisited to minimize instances of a provider backing out before a development is built. Commenter 2 recommends requiring developers to include a Memorandum of Understanding with the educational provider showing the intent of both parties and has provided suggested language to this extent.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 2’s concerns regarding the potential for applicants to back out of Educational Provider Agreements once the development is built. Staff believes there are other methods of enforcing compliance on this item and would recommend bringing this up for further discussion at the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.101(b)(5)(C)(iv)(VIII). Two Elevators

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 2, 8, 15, 20 and 29 appreciate staff’s efforts to make more units accessible to people with disabilities by introducing an incentive to add at least 2 elevators. Additionally, Commenter 2 encourages TDHCA to incentivize projects with accessible units beyond the percent required by state and federal law. Commenter 8 highlights that older adults lack of ability to access higher levels than the ground floor, limiting the number of units that are available to these residents. Commenters 15, 20 and 29 believe this rule will help improve health and safety while also giving tenants more choices to best serve their needs.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 2, 8, 15, 20 and 29’s support on this item.

§11.101(b)(6)(B). Encourage Age-Friendly and Universal Design

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 33 recommends staff build on the visibility requirements, including zero-step entrance, an accessible route to an entry-level bathroom or half-bath, blocking for a future toilet grab bar, and accessible switches, outlets, and thermostats. Commenter 33 explains that Universal design makes housing usable by people of different ages and abilities without requiring costly modifications later and says these features can improve safety, independence and allow residents to remain in their homes as their needs change.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges the recommendations from Commenter 33 to build on the current visibility requirements for units; however, Staff believes it would be too late to add additional visibility requirements before the upcoming 9% Cycle.

§11.101(b)(6)(B)(ii)(VI). Green Building Features

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 13 recommends adding the U.S. Department of Energy’s Efficient New Homes Program (DENH) as a new Green Building Certification.

Commenter 22 suggests updating references to green building standards to the most up-to-date versions and has provided revised language to that extent.

Commenter 24 suggests an additional green building certification, IREM Certified Sustainable Property (CSP) for Affordable Housing, be included as the fifth option under the existing list. Commenter 24 highlights that the other green building certifications listed in the rule do not contain any durable reporting mechanisms and that this certification would require it throughout the life of the property. Commenter 24 has provided suggested language and supplemental information to this extent.

Commenter 40 recommends that the Department recognize, as a one-point Development Construction Feature, the FORTIFIED Roof designation issued by IBHS. Commenter 40 highlights increased wind and hail damage to roofs and recommends the Department include a more advanced system that would better protect from these types of losses. Commenter 40 has provided numerous references and has provided proposed language that they wish to be adopted.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 13, 22, 24 and 40’s comments regarding updating or adding new Green Building Features that provide more advanced sustainability and resiliency features into Tax Credit housing. Staff recommends bringing these recommendations up during the 2028 QAP Roundtables.

§11.101(b)(7). Resident Supportive Services

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 15, 20 and 29 appreciate staff’s inclusion of the 45-day notice requirement to tenants whenever a change to the Resident Supportive services is made. Commenter 20 says this update allows for tenants to have adequate time to make other housing arrangements if their current property no longer meets their needs after a support service is no longer going to be available. Commenter 29 specifies that certain services can be a lifeline, particularly for tenants with disabilities, and providing sufficient notice helps tenants make housing choices and maintain stability.

Commenter 34 requests the removal of the 45-day notice requirement and replacement with the previous, more general requirement. Commenter 34 believes this is unnecessarily restrictive when some circumstances require adjustments on a different timeline. Commenter 34 states allowing reasonable flexibility in the timing of notice, while retaining the obligation to inform residents of changes, would preserve transparency for residents and reduce unnecessary administrative constraints for housing providers.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 15, 20 and 29 for their support on this item.

Staff understands Commenter 34’s concern regarding the 45-day notice requirement and preference for the more general requirement which adds flexibility for the developer. Staff encourages Commenter 34 to bring those ideas to the 2028 QAP Roundtable discussions.

§11.101(b)(8). Accessibility Requirements

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 suggests exempting Rehabilitation developments (excluding Reconstruction) with units accessed by the ground floor or by elevator from complying with visibility requirements in the section.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 17’s suggestion but recommends no change.

§11.204(6)(B). Gap Financing

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 31 and 37 disagree with the timing requirement added that all “All soft or below market rate financing necessary for financial feasibility must be committed by 10% test” for Competitive Applications as well as the caveat added that 10% test extensions will not be granted if the “gap [is] filled by other committed sources”. Commenters 23, 31 and 37 cite interest rate and financing conditions and warn the stricter timing requirement runs contrary to the current market situation and should be tabled until it can be discussed in more detail.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenters 23, 31, and 37’s concerns regarding current interest rate and financing conditions. Staff believes, however, that requiring all soft or below-market financing necessary for financial feasibility to be committed by the 10% Test is an appropriate measure to ensure that Competitive Developments are making meaningful progress toward closing and construction. Requiring financing gaps to be resolved by the 10% Test provides greater certainty that a Development is positioned to move forward and place units in service.

§11.204(9). Site Control, Identity of Interest Transactions

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 34 requests clarification regarding Identity of Interest Transaction requirements to distinguish legitimate land banking from transactions involving an actual identity of interest between the parties. Commenter 34 states that Affordable housing developers often acquire and hold sites for several years while pursuing financing, assembling project resources, and awaiting a competitive opportunity to receive housing tax credits. Commenter 34 has provided specific examples and suggested language covering the extent of the issues raised in their comment.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 34’s request for clarification regarding Identity of Interest Transactions and land banking. Staff believes the suggested changes warrant additional discussion with staff and industry stakeholders. Staff encourages Commenter 34 to raise the issue during the 2028 QAP Roundtables or initial staff draft discussions.

§11.204(9)(D).  Ingress and Egress

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 17, 23, 25, 27 and 38 suggest restoring the stricken 2026 language requiring the documentation for easements, leaseholds or similar documentation to be provided at the time of Commitment, Determination Notice, or Contract. Commenters 17, 23, 25, 27 and 38 believe issues like this take time to work through and requiring this information at Application will be very difficult to achieve.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 23, 25, 27, and 38. Staff has made a responsive change to this section

§11.204(9)(E). Vacation Right of Way

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 17, 23, 25, 27 and 38 believe this section should only apply to vacations of rights of way and not plat vacations. Commenters 23, 25, 27 and 38 have provided additional context and suggested language to this extent.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 23, 25, 27, and 38. Staff has made a responsive change to this section

§11.205(4). Appraisal

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 requests adding back the sentence which states appraisals are required for identity of interest transactions and developments requesting acquisition credits.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17’s request to restore the language clarifying when appraisals are required. The proposed changes were intended to address inconsistencies between the Third-Party Report requirements, Underwriting Rules, and Appraisal Rules that have created confusion, particularly for 9% and Multifamily Direct Loan layered Developments.

Staff agrees that the appraisal requirement should be clearly stated in the Third-Party Report requirements and has made a responsive change to restore the language. Staff has also clarified that an appraisal may be required not only for Identity of Interest Transactions and Developments requesting acquisition credits, but also when required under the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act (URA).

§11.302(d). Operating Feasibility for Tax-Exempt Bond Developments

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 23, 25 and 38 wish to retain the streamlined process for tax-exempt bond developments that do not request direct loan funds or in which TDHCA is the issuer of the bonds. Commenters 23, 25 and 38 state that the financial risks are held with the owner, lenders and investors of a project and that the Department’s review of this will be using a different set of assumptions.

Commenters 25 and 38 recommend that if the Department chooses to apply its own expense estimates, it should have the Underwriter give weight to property-level, portfolio, lender, investor, and issuer data, and that the final rule retain the current §11.302(d)(3) language allowing actual Net Operating Income at cost certification to be adjusted for stabilization of rents and extraordinary lease -up expenses.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenters 23, 25, and 38’s concerns regarding the proposed underwriting requirements for Tax-Exempt Bond Developments. Based on current market conditions and issues identified through recent cost certification reviews, Staff believes it is appropriate for the Department to evaluate operating expenses as part of determining whether a Development meets the Department’s underwriting requirements and operating feasibility.

Applicants may continue to provide supporting information regarding their assumed expenses through responses to Requests for Information, and Staff will consider that information as part of the underwriting review.

Regarding the recommendation to retain language addressing adjustments to Net Operating Income at cost certification, Staff does not believe that provision should be included in the Underwriting Rules because the treatment of Net Operating Income at cost certification is addressed through the Department’s Asset Management rules.

§11.302(d)(2). Expenses

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 17, 25 and 38 request reinstatement of language related to the expense category descriptions as the proposed language may cause confusion.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 25, and 38’s request to reinstate the language describing the expense categories. Staff agrees that the additional language provides useful clarification and has made a responsive change to restore it.

§11.302(d)(2)(G) and §11.302(g)(2). Insurance and Underwriting

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 40 states the proposed rule deletes the description of the Insurance Expense, “cost of insurance coverage for the buildings, contents, and general liability,” and leaves only what the line excludes. Commenter 40 recommends the Department retain the description and names of the coverages and has provided recommended language to this extent. Additionally, Commenter 40 has provided specific examples from various housing developments and their insurance costs along the Texas coast.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 40’s comments regarding the Insurance Expense description and the additional information provided regarding insurance costs along the Texas coast. Staff agrees that the description of the Insurance Expense should be reinstated and has made a responsive change to restore the language. Staff has also added clarification that windstorm, hail, and flood coverage should be included where applicable.

§11.302(e)(6). General Contractor Fee

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 23, 25 and 38 request the provision requiring the fees paid for sales tax exemptions be charged to the general contractor fee limit, as those fees are paid to the NP partner and not the general partner.  Commenters 25 and 38 highlight this as a 2026 rule. Commenters 25 and 38 further specific that such fees should be reasonable, but a sales tax -exempt General Contractor and the performing Prime Subcontractor are unrelated entities, and the exemption fee should not count against the performing contractor’s limit.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 23, 25, and 38’s comments regarding fees associated with sales tax exemptions. This issue was discussed with the Board and industry during the 2026 rulemaking process, and the Department determined that these fees should be included within the General Contractor fee limit.

Where the nonprofit entity serves as the General Contractor and elects to charge a fee associated with providing the sales tax exemption, Staff believes that fee should remain subject to the General Contractor fee limitation.

§11.302(e)(9). Reserves

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenters 17, 25, 27 and 38 request the reinstatement of language related to exemptions of certain projects and documented operating reserve rules and have provided suggested edits to this extent.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenters 17, 25, 27, and 38’s request for clarification regarding exemptions and operating reserve requirements. Staff agrees that the language stating, “Except for underwriting a Housing Tax Credit Development at Cost Certification,” provides useful clarification and has made a responsive change to reinstate it.

Staff does not believe the reference to §11.204 relating to Operating Reserve Accounts needs to be reinstated because those requirements are not part of the upfront underwriting performed by REA and are only reviewed at Cost Certification. The applicable requirements are addressed in the Department’s Asset Management rules.

§11.901(2). Fee Schedule

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 requests the nonprofit description be modified so any nonprofit organization qualifies for the 10% discount. Commenter 17 provided suggested language to reflect their request.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 17 on their request to modify the description for any nonprofit organization to qualify for the 10% discount. Staff encourages Commenter 17 to bring this topic up during the 2028 QAP Roundtable for further discussion.

§11.902(a). Appeals Process

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 17 questions why the Tax-Exempt Bond language referencing §1.7 is deleted.  Commenter 17 also questions why not reference the appeals process for each program covered by the QAP, not just the 9% program.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff appreciates Commenter 17 for bringing up this issue regarding the appeals process. Staff has made a responsive change to this section for clarity.

Other Comments

Two-Year QAP

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 2 recommends updating the QAP every two years in alignment with the legislative sessions rather than annually. Commenter 2 believes this would be more efficient for the department and will allow for more certainty for developers working within the program.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff acknowledges Commenter 2’s request for updating the QAP every two years to align with the Texas Legislative Session.  Staff encourages Commenter 2 to bring this topic up during the 2028 QAP Roundtable for further discussion.

Safety of Apartment Complexes

COMMENT SUMMARY:

Commenter 39 references an explosion that occurred in the Oak Cliff neighborhood of Dallas following a gas leak. Commenter 39 specifies that they intend to file legislation to help prevent further similar tragedies.

STAFF RESPONSE:

Staff truly appreciates Commenter 39’s comment and their efforts to ensure safety for Texans. The Department is available as a resource to assist Commenter 39 in their efforts. In direct response to the incident referenced in the comment, the Department updated its Tenant Rights and Resources Guide, which must be provided to every household that moves into a Department-assisted property, to include safety information about natural gas.